Honestly Compared logoHonestlyCompared
HEAD-TO-HEAD • HONEST VERDICTS
Home › Comparisons › Air Fryers › Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer vs Ninja Foodi XL

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer vs Ninja Foodi XL: Which Should You Buy?

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900) vs Ninja Foodi XL (DT251) side by side

Two big stainless boxes. Two 1,800-watt heating systems. Two different ideas about what a countertop oven should be.

The Breville is the precision instrument. Six quartz elements, a PID temperature controller, and a temperature range that runs from a gentle 80°F proof to a 480°F sear.

The Ninja is the family production line. It preheats in 90 seconds, cooks on two levels at once, and watches your roast for you with a built-in thermometer.

Before the specs, one naming warning, because both badges are traps. The Breville here is the BOV900 — launched as the Smart Oven Air, now sold as the Smart Oven® Air Fryer Pro. The Ninja is the DT251 Foodi 10-in-1 Smart XL Air Fry Oven — the XL countertop oven, not a Foodi pressure cooker or basket fryer. Pin those model numbers down and the comparison gets honest fast.

Key Takeaways

  • The Ninja Foodi XL (DT251) is the better family oven. Two-level cooking, a 90-second preheat and an integrated thermometer make weeknight dinners faster and harder to get wrong.
  • The Breville (BOV900) is the better cooking instrument. A wider 80–480°F range, Element IQ power steering with PID control, 13 functions and room for a 13-inch pizza or a 5-qt Dutch oven.
  • Capacity is a shape, not a size. The Breville takes the bigger single items; the Ninja cooks two levels of food at the same time.
  • Cleaning splits oddly. Ninja’s basket and racks may go in the dishwasher; its pans may not. Breville recommends hand-washing everything.
  • Warranty is not close. Breville covers the BOV900 for two years. SharkNinja covers the DT251 for one.

Quick Verdict

Buy the Ninja Foodi XL (DT251) for family cooking. It is the oven that gets dinner done.

Two sheet-pan levels cook at once, with no rotating. The preheat takes 90 seconds. The Foodi Smart Thermometer cooks a chicken or a roast to your chosen doneness and tells you when to pull it.

For households cooking real meals four or five nights a week, those features beat everything else on this page.

Buy the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900) if you cook like a baker, not a caterer. Its 80–480°F range proofs dough, slow-cooks, dehydrates and still sears hotter than the Ninja.

Its Element IQ system steers power between six quartz elements under PID control, so set temperatures are held properly. It fits a 13-inch pizza and a 5-qt Dutch oven the Ninja cannot take. And it carries a two-year warranty.

The Scorecard

Scores below are derived directly from the manufacturer specifications compared in this guide — capacities, temperature ranges, function lists, included accessories and warranty terms. They are a reading aid, not benchmark results.

CategoryBreville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900)Ninja Foodi XL (DT251)
Capacity & fit
9 / 10
9 / 10
Cooking design & temperature control
9 / 10
8 / 10
Functions & versatility
9 / 10
8 / 10
Speed & everyday ease
7 / 10
9 / 10
Cleaning
6 / 10
7 / 10
Footprint
7 / 10
8 / 10
Value in the box
7 / 10
8 / 10
Overall7.7 / 108.1 / 10

Read the pattern, not just the totals. The Breville wins every category about the cooking itself. The Ninja wins every category about the cooking day — speed, guidance, cleaning, footprint. Your household’s bottleneck decides which column matters.

At a Glance: Who Each Oven Fits

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer BOV900 countertop oven — manufacturer image

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900)

  • 1.0 cu ft cavity: 13-in pizza, 14-lb turkey, 5-qt Dutch oven
  • 80–480°F range; Element IQ + PID temperature control
  • 13 functions, including Proof, Slow Cook and Cookies
  • Two-stage Phase Cook button on the panel
  • 2-year limited warranty
View on Amazon
Ninja Foodi XL DT251 Smart XL Air Fry Oven — manufacturer image

Ninja Foodi XL (DT251)

  • Two-level cooking: a 5-lb chicken and a sheet pan of vegetables at once
  • Integrated Foodi Smart Thermometer with doneness presets
  • 90-second preheat; rack levels light up to guide placement
  • 10 functions, 85–450°F, True Surround Convection
  • Two sheet pans, two racks, basket, roast tray and crumb tray included
View on Amazon

Choose the Breville BOV900 if…

You bake seriously. Bread, pizza on a stone-hot pan, traybakes in 9×13 pans, a Dutch oven of stew on Slow Cook.

You proof dough, dehydrate in quantity, or cook low and slow — jobs that live below 180°F, where the Ninja barely operates.

You want the oven that holds a set temperature properly, sears at 480°F, and is still covered by its warranty in year two.

Choose the Ninja Foodi XL DT251 if…

You cook family dinners against the clock. Two levels at once, a 90-second preheat, and no pan rotation is a weeknight system, not a spec.

You roast meat and poultry often. The integrated thermometer removes the guesswork that ruins more roasts than any oven does.

Your counter is tight on width or depth. The Ninja is the slightly smaller box, and it lights up the correct rack level for every function.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Specifications: The Specs That Actually Matter

Every figure below comes from Breville’s and SharkNinja’s published product data and owner’s manuals. Where a retailer data field disagrees with the manufacturer, the manufacturer wins — and the disagreements worth knowing about are flagged under the table.

SpecificationBreville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900)Ninja Foodi XL (DT251)
Model / SKUBOV900 (BOV900BSSUSC), brushed stainless steelDT251, silver / stainless finish
Capacity1.0 cu ft — 9 toast slices, 14-lb turkey, 13-in pizza, most 9×13 pans, 12-cup muffin tray, 5-qt Dutch ovenTwo-level cooking — 5-lb chicken plus a sheet pan of vegetables at once, two 12-in pizzas, or a 12-lb turkey; 9 toast slices
Power1,800 W1,800 W
Temperature range80–480°F across functions85–450°F (Dehydrate from 85°F; Bake and Pizza from 180°F; Air Fry, Air Roast and Whole Roast from 250°F)
Cooking functions13: Toast, Bagel, Broil, Bake, Roast, Warm, Pizza, Proof, Air Fry, Reheat, Cookies, Slow Cook, Dehydrate10: Air Fry, Whole Roast, Air Roast, Bake, Dehydrate, Pizza, Bagel, Toast, Broil, Reheat
Heating & control6 independent quartz elements; Element IQ power steering with PID temperature sensingTrue Surround Convection (up to 10× the convection power of a traditional full-size convection oven, per SharkNinja)
Meat thermometerNot includedIntegrated Foodi Smart Thermometer with preset and manual doneness targets
Racks & levels4 rack grooves; two reversible racks give 8 positions; dehydrates up to 4 trays4 rack levels; designed for simultaneous 2-level cooking; panel illuminates the recommended level per function
Included accessories13-in non-stick pizza pan, 2 wire racks, 9×13 broiling rack, 9×13 enamel roasting pan, air fry / dehydrate mesh basket2 sheet pans, 2 wire racks, air fry basket, roast tray, crumb tray, Foodi Smart Thermometer, recipe guide
PreheatStandard preheat cycle with ready alert90-second preheat (manufacturer figure)
Dimensions (W × D × H)21.4 × 17.3 × 12.7 in20.22 × 17.09 × 13.34 in — narrower and shallower, but taller
Dishwasher-safe partsNone rated — Breville does not recommend dishwashing the accessoriesAir fry basket and wire racks only (hand-wash recommended; sheet pan, roast tray and crumb tray must not be dishwashed)
Warranty2-year limited1-year limited

Naming note: Breville renamed this oven. The BOV900 launched in 2017 as “the Smart Oven Air”; Breville’s current US store sells the same SKU as “the Smart Oven® Air Fryer Pro.” It is one oven with two names, not two models — and it is not the smaller BOV860 that also wears a “Smart Oven Air Fryer” badge, nor the app-connected Joule BOV950.

Capacity note: SharkNinja publishes no cubic-foot figure for the DT251 — only the fit list used above. Retailer data fields variously claim “12 liters” or “2.67 cu ft” for the same oven; neither comes from SharkNinja, and neither is used here.

Range note: the Ninja’s 85°F floor exists only on Dehydrate. Its everyday cooking functions start far higher — 180°F on Bake and Pizza, 250°F on Air Fry, Air Roast and Whole Roast. The Breville’s 80°F floor, by contrast, belongs to working functions: Proof and Slow Cook.

The Differences That Actually Matter

1. First, the names — because both badges mislead

Start here, or you will compare the wrong ovens. “Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer” has been printed on more than one box.

The oven in this comparison is the BOV900: Breville’s 1.0 cu ft flagship, launched as the Smart Oven Air and currently sold by Breville US as the Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro. Same SKU, same oven, new name.

It is not the BOV860, a smaller stablemate that also carries a Smart Oven Air Fryer badge. And it is not the BOV950 Joule, Breville’s app-connected flagship, which is a different purchase again.

“Ninja Foodi XL” is just as slippery. Foodi badges pressure cookers, basket fryers, flip-up ovens and grills.

Against a Breville countertop oven, the comparison market means the XL oven line — and its fullest expression is the DT251 Foodi 10-in-1 Smart XL Air Fry Oven. That is the oven compared here: 20.22 inches wide, two cooking levels, integrated thermometer.

Its sibling, the DT201, is the same oven without the thermometer. Everything in this guide about capacity, range and accessories applies to both; the thermometer sections apply to the DT251 alone.

2. Temperature — the Breville’s home turf

The headline numbers are 80–480°F against 85–450°F. The real story is where those ranges live.

The Breville’s range is usable. Proof works down at dough-friendly temperatures. Slow Cook holds a braise for hours. Dehydrate, Bake and Roast all sit inside one continuous, finely adjustable span.

Six quartz elements do the heating, and Element IQ moves power between them depending on the function. A PID controller senses the cavity and trims output to hold the set point. That is how a countertop oven should be built, and almost none are.

The Ninja’s 85°F floor is a dehydrate-only figure. Air Fry, Air Roast and Whole Roast start at 250°F. Bake and Pizza start at 180°F.

In practice, the Ninja cannot proof dough, cannot slow-cook, and cannot hold the gentle temperatures delicate baking asks for. Its ceiling is also 30 degrees lower: 450°F against 480°F, which shows up in pizza and finishing sears.

If temperature craft is your cooking, this section settles the comparison on its own. The Breville wins it outright.

3. Capacity — one big cavity against two working levels

Both ovens are “XL.” They spend the space in opposite directions.

The Breville’s 1.0 cu ft cavity takes the bigger single things: a 13-inch pizza, a 14-lb turkey, a 12-cup muffin tray, most 9×13 pans, and a 5-qt Dutch oven with the lid on. One large job, done properly, at one level.

The Ninja takes a 12-inch pizza and a 12-lb turkey — a step down on both. What it does instead is stack: a 5-lb chicken on the roast tray below, a sheet pan of vegetables above, both cooking at the same time, with convection designed to make rotation unnecessary.

That is a complete family dinner in one run. The Breville would cook the chicken and vegetables in sequence, or crowd them onto one level.

Multi-tray work cuts the other way once: for dehydrating, the Breville handles up to four trays against the Ninja’s two levels (four only with an extra accessory). Batch bakers and jerky makers, note it.

Verdict: a genuine split. Big single items, Breville. Whole meals at once, Ninja. We score capacity level because both claims are real.

4. The thermometer against Phase Cook

Each oven has one signature trick. They aim at opposite cooks.

The Ninja’s is the Foodi Smart Thermometer. Plug it in, pick a protein and a doneness — or set a manual target — and the oven tracks the internal temperature and finishes at the number, not at a guess.

Roast chicken, beef joints and pork are where ovens earn or lose their keep, and most failures are temperature failures. The DT251 automates exactly that failure away. Its cheaper sibling, the DT201, deletes this feature entirely — it is the main reason to buy the DT251 badge.

The Breville’s trick is Phase Cook: two functions chained in one program, set from a dedicated panel button. Start with a hot Air Fry to crisp, finish with a gentle Bake. Sear, then slow. No mid-cook intervention.

Phase Cook rewards cooks who already know what they are doing. The thermometer rescues cooks who are still learning, or simply busy. Know which one you are.

5. Functions — thirteen against ten, and the gaps are specific

The Breville’s 13 functions: Toast, Bagel, Broil, Bake, Roast, Warm, Pizza, Proof, Air Fry, Reheat, Cookies, Slow Cook, Dehydrate.

The Ninja’s 10: Air Fry, Whole Roast, Air Roast, Bake, Dehydrate, Pizza, Bagel, Toast, Broil, Reheat.

The overlap is large — every everyday job exists on both panels. The differences are the Breville’s Proof, Slow Cook, Cookies and dedicated Warm, against the Ninja’s Whole Roast, a mode tuned for a protein plus sides across two levels.

Read that as philosophy. Breville’s extra functions extend what the oven can be: a proofer, a slow cooker, a small bakery. Ninja’s extends how much dinner it can produce at once.

Neither list is padded. But if your cooking ever goes below 180°F, only one of these ovens follows you there.

6. Speed, guidance and the shape of the box

SharkNinja publishes a 90-second preheat for the DT251, and claims cooking up to 30% faster than a traditional full-size convection oven. Breville makes a similar speed claim for its super convection — but publishes no preheat figure to match the 90 seconds.

The Ninja also coaches placement. Choose a function and the panel lights the recommended rack level; press 2 LEVEL and it re-plans for two trays. Wrong-level cooking is a quiet cause of bad results, and the Ninja designs it out.

The Breville answers with the better interface for experienced hands: three big dials, a clear LCD, and a magnetic auto-eject rack that nudges food toward you when the door opens.

On the counter, the Ninja is narrower (20.22 vs 21.4 in) and slightly shallower, but taller (13.34 vs 12.7 in). Measure your under-cabinet height before assuming the smaller footprint wins — on a short counter run, the Breville’s lower lid line may be the one that fits.

7. Cleaning — read the fine print on both

Here is the section the marketing departments would skip.

Breville’s instruction book is blunt: it does not recommend putting the BOV900’s accessories in the dishwasher. The enamel roasting pan, broiling rack, pizza pan and mesh basket are hand-wash parts. The non-stick cavity walls wipe down, and the crumb tray slides out — but the accessory set is a sink job.

The Ninja looks better and is better — narrowly. Its air fry basket and wire racks may go in the dishwasher, though SharkNinja recommends hand-washing and warns they may wear faster.

But the Ninja’s sheet pans, roast tray and crumb tray — the parts that catch the grease — must not be dishwashed, or their finishes degrade. The thermometer is hand-wash only and must never go in the dishwasher at all.

So the honest summary: the Ninja lets you dishwash the basket and racks; everything greasy, on both ovens, is washed by hand. The Ninja wins cleaning, by less than its brochure suggests.

Which Oven Fits Your Household?

Start from who is eating and what a normal week looks like. This table is the comparison in one view.

Your household / use caseBreville BOV900Ninja Foodi XL DT251Our call
Solo or couple, mostly small mealsOversized for the jobOversized for the jobNeither — see When to Skip Both
Family of 3–5, weeknight dinnersStrong — one level at a timeExcellent — protein and sides togetherNinja DT251
Serious home bakerExcellent — Proof, PID control, 9×13 pansCapable — no Proof, higher floorBreville BOV900
Pizza nightsExcellent — 13-in pizza, 480°FGood — 12-in pizza, 450°FBreville BOV900
Roast dinners and holiday birdsExcellent — 14-lb turkey, Dutch oven roomExcellent — 12-lb turkey, thermometer finishBreville for size; Ninja for certainty
Meal prep and batch cookingExcellent — up to 4 dehydrate traysExcellent — two sheet-pan levelsSplit: dehydrating Breville, sheet pans Ninja
Small kitchen, tight countersShorter, but wider and deeperNarrower, but tallerMeasure height first — then decide

Ready to check today’s price?

Both ovens sell through Amazon under several look-alike names. Use these links to land on the exact models compared here — BOV900 and DT251.

View on Amazon — Breville BOV900View on Amazon — Ninja DT251

The 30-Second Decision

If this sounds like you…Buy this
“Dinner for four, on the table fast, most nights.”Ninja Foodi XL (DT251)
“I bake bread and want a proofing drawer that also roasts.”Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900)
“My roasts are either dry or underdone. Fix that.”Ninja Foodi XL (DT251) — the thermometer
“Thirteen-inch pizzas and a Dutch oven are non-negotiable.”Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900)
“I want the longest warranty on the counter.”Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900) — 2 years
“I hate washing pans and want the dishwasher to help.”Ninja Foodi XL (DT251) — basket and racks only

What You Gain. What You Give Up.

Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900)

You gain: the widest, most usable temperature range in the class (80–480°F). PID-held precision across 13 functions, including Proof and Slow Cook. The biggest single-item capacity here — 13-in pizza, 14-lb turkey, 5-qt Dutch oven. Phase Cook two-stage programs. A two-year warranty.

You give up: speed and simultaneity. One level cooks at a time, there is no integrated thermometer, and no accessory is rated for the dishwasher. It is also the wider, deeper box on the counter.

Ninja Foodi XL (DT251)

You gain: two-level family cooking with a 90-second preheat. An integrated thermometer that finishes roasts by temperature, not by guess. Guided rack placement on every function. A slightly smaller footprint and a deeper accessory bundle — two sheet pans, two racks, basket, roast tray and thermometer in the box.

You give up: the low end of the dial. No proofing, no slow cooking, everyday functions that start at 180–250°F, and a 450°F ceiling. A 12-inch pizza limit. And a warranty that expires a full year earlier.

Pros and Cons

Breville BOV900 — Pros

  • 80–480°F range with PID temperature holding
  • 13 functions, including Proof and Slow Cook
  • Fits a 13-in pizza and a 5-qt Dutch oven
  • Phase Cook two-stage cooking from the panel
  • 2-year limited warranty

Cons

  • No integrated thermometer
  • Cooks one level at a time
  • No dishwasher-rated accessories
  • Widest and deepest footprint here

Ninja Foodi XL DT251 — Pros

  • Two-level cooking, no rotation needed
  • Integrated Foodi Smart Thermometer
  • 90-second preheat; guided rack levels
  • Generous accessory bundle in the box
  • Basket and racks are dishwasher-tolerant

Cons

  • No Proof or Slow Cook; high per-function floors
  • 450°F ceiling; 12-in pizza limit
  • Sheet pans and roast tray are hand-wash only
  • 1-year limited warranty

Buy the Model Number, Not the Badge

Check the Breville SKU. The BOV900 is sold under two names — originally the Smart Oven Air, today the Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro. Both names on a listing should still resolve to model BOV900 (brushed stainless SKU BOV900BSSUSC).

Two neighbours are not this oven. The BOV860 is a smaller Smart Oven Air Fryer. The BOV950 Joule adds Wi-Fi and an app for more money. If a listing’s dimensions are not 21.4 × 17.3 × 12.7 inches, it is not the oven in this comparison.

Check the Ninja trim. The DT251 and DT201 share a body, a range and an accessory layout. The difference is the integrated thermometer, and it is the DT251’s whole point.

A cheaper DT201 listing is not a bargain version of this oven — it is this oven minus its best feature. Also note the refurbished market: Renewed DT251 units circulate widely and are not the new product the buttons in this guide point to.

Check the accessory count. The DT251 box should hold two sheet pans, two wire racks, the air fry basket, the roast tray, the crumb tray and the thermometer. A listing offering one sheet pan is describing a different bundle.

The BOV900 box should hold the 13-in pizza pan, two racks, the 9×13 broiling rack and enamel pan, and the mesh basket.

Check your counter before either. Both ovens need air space around them, and the Ninja’s extra height surprises people. Measure width, depth and cabinet height as three separate numbers.

The Upgrade Path Test

Judge a countertop oven by its third year, not its first week.

The Breville’s third year looks like breadth. The oven that proofed your first sourdough is the one slow-cooking Sunday’s ragu. Functions you ignored at purchase — Proof, Slow Cook, Dehydrate — tend to get adopted over time, and the two-year warranty covers the period when early faults appear.

Its wear points are honest ones: the accessories are hand-wash for life. Nothing about the BOV900 becomes obsolete, because it was never connected to anything.

The Ninja’s third year looks like routine. The thermometer probe is the part to watch — it is a cabled accessory with its own storage holder, hand-wash only, and the oven’s best feature depends on it. Treat it well and the DT251 stays a system; lose it and you own a DT201.

SharkNinja sells a deep accessory catalogue for the platform, including extra dehydrate racks. Breville sells replacement pans and racks for the BOV900 as well. Neither oven strands you.

The real divergence is direction. The Breville grows with your skills. The Ninja grows with your household. Pick the growth you actually expect.

When to Skip Both

Honesty cuts both ways. Some kitchens should buy neither of these.

Skip both if you cook for one or two and rarely roast. A compact oven or a good basket fryer will do the same jobs on a third of the counter — Breville’s own smaller ovens, or Ninja’s flip-up line that stores against the backsplash.

Skip both if you want an app. The connected version of this fight is Breville’s Joule BOV950 against Ninja’s newer Prestige ovens; neither oven in this guide has Wi-Fi, and neither pretends to.

Skip both if a 13-inch-plus pizza, a 9×13 casserole dish with handles, or a large Dutch oven is your weekly norm and even the Breville’s cavity feels tight. That is a full-size range’s job, and no countertop oven wins it.

And skip both if your kitchen circuit is already loaded. Each oven wants 1,800 watts and a circuit largely to itself.

For everyone else — families feeding four or more, bakers, roast devotees — one of these two is the right answer. The only question is which kind of cooking runs your kitchen.

Final Verdict

The Ninja Foodi XL (DT251) is the oven we would put on most counters.

It wins this comparison on the shape of real life. Dinner is two things that need to finish together. Roasts fail on internal temperature, not on effort. Preheat time is dead time, and 90 seconds of it beats several minutes.

The DT251 answers all three: two-level cooking, an integrated thermometer, and the fastest start in the class. Its 8.1 overall score reflects how completely it is aimed at the family kitchen.

Buy the Ninja DT251 for family dinners, roast meats and poultry, meal-prep sheet pans, and any household that cooks against the clock.

View on Amazon — Ninja Foodi XL (DT251)

Buy the Breville BOV900 if your cooking is a craft. It is the more precise instrument by a wide margin: an 80–480°F working range, PID-held temperatures, Proof and Slow Cook, a 13-inch pizza span, room for a Dutch oven, and a warranty twice as long.

Bakers, pizza makers and low-and-slow cooks are not buying the runner-up. They are buying the correct oven, and its 7.7 score says only that it is specialised, not lesser.

View on Amazon — Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV900)

Watch Out: Similar Names, Different Ovens

Countertop oven names are a trap for the hurried buyer. Four warnings belong in every version of this guide.

First: “Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro” is the BOV900’s current name — but Breville also sells the Joule Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV950), an app-connected model at a higher price. Check for the model number, not the word “Pro.”

Second: a smaller Breville, the BOV800/BOV860 line, wears Smart Oven Air Fryer badges too. It is a fine oven and a different, smaller one. The 21.4-inch width is the BOV900’s fingerprint.

Third: “Ninja Foodi” alone tells you almost nothing — the badge covers pressure cookers, grills and basket fryers. The Foodi XL oven is the DT series. Within it, DT251 means thermometer included; DT201 means thermometer deleted; the newer Prestige DT501/DT551 models are a separate generation with different specifications.

Fourth: both ovens circulate as Renewed or refurbished units at tempting prices. Those listings are not the new products linked in this guide, and warranty terms differ. Read the condition line before the price line.

Warranty and Long-Term Support

The warranty gap is the clearest number in this comparison: Breville covers the BOV900 for two years; SharkNinja covers the DT251 for one year, under its standard one-year limited warranty.

Both brands run mature support operations with published manuals, replacement accessories and parts channels. Breville sells replacement racks, pans and baskets for the BOV900; SharkNinja’s accessory store covers the DT251’s pans, racks and thermometer ecosystem.

Two ownership habits matter more than either brand’s promises. Keep the Ninja’s thermometer cabled, stored in its holder and hand-washed — it is the feature you paid for. And on the Breville, hand-washing is the price of the enamel and non-stick finishes staying intact.

Register either oven at purchase. On a one-year warranty especially, the registration date is the coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer the same as the Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro?

Yes, in this comparison both names mean the BOV900. Breville launched the oven as the Smart Oven Air and later renamed it the Smart Oven® Air Fryer Pro; the SKU (BOV900BSSUSC) did not change. It is a separate product from the smaller BOV860 and from the app-connected Joule BOV950.

Which Ninja Foodi XL is in this comparison?

The DT251 Foodi 10-in-1 Smart XL Air Fry Oven — the XL countertop oven with the integrated Foodi Smart Thermometer. The DT201 is the same oven without the thermometer. The comparison does not cover Foodi pressure cookers, basket fryers or the flip-up SP-series ovens.

Which oven fits more food?

It depends on the shape of the food. The Breville’s 1.0 cu ft cavity takes bigger single items: a 13-in pizza, a 14-lb turkey, most 9×13 pans and a 5-qt Dutch oven. The Ninja takes a 12-in pizza or a 12-lb turkey, but cooks on two levels at once — a 5-lb chicken plus a sheet pan of vegetables in a single run.

Which oven is better for baking?

The Breville. Its Element IQ system with PID control holds set temperatures precisely, its range starts at 80°F with a dedicated Proof function, and it fits standard 9×13 pans and a 12-cup muffin tray. The Ninja bakes well but has no Proof function and its Bake range starts at 180°F.

Can either oven replace a full-size oven?

For most households, mostly. Both are 1,800 W countertop ovens that toast, bake, roast, air fry and reheat, and both take a holiday bird (14 lb in the Breville, 12 lb in the Ninja). Very large casseroles, multiple simultaneous trays of baking, and the biggest Dutch ovens still belong in a full-size range.

Are the accessories dishwasher safe?

On the Ninja, only the air fry basket and wire racks may go in the dishwasher, and SharkNinja recommends hand-washing; the sheet pans, roast tray and crumb tray must not be dishwashed, and the thermometer is hand-wash only. On the Breville, the instruction book does not recommend dishwashing any of the accessories.

What warranties do they carry?

The Breville BOV900 carries a 2-year limited warranty. The Ninja DT251 carries SharkNinja’s 1-year limited warranty. Both are limited warranties covering defects under normal household use for the original purchaser.

Is the Ninja’s thermometer worth choosing the DT251 over the DT201?

For most buyers, yes. The DT251 and DT201 are the same oven apart from the integrated Foodi Smart Thermometer, and that thermometer is the feature that changes outcomes — roasts and poultry finished by internal temperature rather than by timer and hope. If you never cook whole proteins, the DT201 is the rational saving.

Sources & Verification

Breville US product page for the BOV900 (“the Smart Oven® Air Fryer Pro,” SKU BOV900BSSUSC: capacity fit list, 13 functions, Element IQ with PID control, dimensions, accessories) • Breville BOV900 instruction book (temperature control 80–480°F, accessory set, Phase Cook, dishwasher guidance) • SharkNinja DT251 owner’s guide (functions and per-function temperature ranges, 4 rack positions, accessory care and dishwasher limits, thermometer care, one-year limited warranty) • SharkNinja DT251 manufacturer product data via retail spec sheets (dimensions, 1-year limited warranty, included components) • Amazon.com product data for DT251 (model, UPC 622356563567) and BOV900, cross-checked against independent retail and specification records. Specifications verified November 2026.

James Wilson

James Wilson

James has been building and benchmarking PCs for over a decade and writes Honestly Compared's motherboard and component guides. His rule for every comparison: the verdict has to survive the spec sheet, not the marketing page.

Affiliate disclosure: Honestly Compared is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Links to Amazon on this page are affiliate links — if you buy through them we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. It never changes a verdict.